top of page
Search

Contrasting Generations of Baseball Players

Nov 6
5 min read

Watching the major league baseball playoffs and the World Series recently (unfortunately, my team lost in the second round of the playoffs), I happened to recall a book I had purchased several years ago but had never had time to read. Being at a "waiting period" in my current writing work in progress, I decided that now would be a good time to read it.



The book is a history of the Southern League, a constantly changing minor league association with a long and varied pedigree. The game of baseball had been played in the South even before the War Between the States. After the war, nine teams joined together to form the National Association of Professional Baseball Players, which five years later became what we now know as the National League. By 1884, there were three major leagues and eight minor leagues.


Baseball was a much different game in those days. The rules were quite different. For example, the mound was only 50 feet from home plate. Pitchers "twirled" the ball underhanded. The ball was "dead," meaning it didn't jump from the bat at great velocity and didn't travel as far when it was hit, so there were fewer extra-base hits, especially home runs. There was only one umpire, and he called balls and strikes from 40 feet or more behind the plate. If runners were on base, he called the balls and strikes from behind the pitcher. To obtain a walk required seven balls rather than today's four. And every player not only played his position but also batter, even the pitchers. No designated hitters.


The book then discussed the various cities that fielded teams in those minor leagues, focusing on those in the South, and the players who were members of the teams. Some of those cities fielded teams only for a year or two, then dropped out, only to rejoin a few years later. The league memberships were constantly changing, and seasons quite often ended early because there weren't enough teams left to afford true competition.


I was amazed, however, by the feats of the players or yore and couldn't help contrasting them with players today.


The first player whose feats caught my attention was Bill Hart, a 19-year-old who played for Chattanooga in 1885. He sometimes would have to pitch three or four games in a row because the other pitcher in the rotation would mysteriously disappear. In one such instance, he pitched four consecutive games and won all four of them. When he wasn't pitching, he was playing right field or pinch hitting. Similarly, Abner Powell, playing for the New Orleans Pelicans, played two years as not only a pitcher but also as outfielder, infielder, and catcher. He later would be a successful player-manager.


Glenn Liebhardt, hurler for Memphis
Glenn Liebhardt, hurler for Memphis

Another strongman was pitcher Glenn Liebhardt, who reputedly had "the greatest spitball in the circuit." When he was hired, the Memphis manager told him he expected him to finish every game he started. In 1906, he started 46 games and completed 45 of them, failing to finish only one and that because he was ejected from the game in the seventh inning for arguing with the umpire over a called ball.


As amazing as that feat would be today, with pitchers being limited to 70 or 80 pitches, it was not uncommon back then for pitchers to pitch complete games. It has become rare today for anyone to pitch a complete game, even when he is pitching a no-hitter. Liebhardt also pitched two 11-inning complete games and two 12-inning complete games. He pitched five doubleheaders and won nine of those ten games.


In those early days, teams were limited to 14 players, so it wasn't as easy to substitute players during a game. Few, if any, relief pitchers. Few, if any, pinch hitters or pinch runners. The 25-player roster limit of today would have been considered an unnecessary luxury back in the early days of the game.


Kaiser Wilhelm
Kaiser Wilhelm

In 1907, pitcher Kaiser Wilhelm (aka "Little Eva") set a record for consecutive innings pitched with 56, and 11 of those games were shutouts. That same year, he pitched five doubleheaders, and in one of the doubleheaders he shut out the opponents in both games.


Players in "the good ol' days" not only had to be physically and mentally tough to accomplish such feats but also had to truly love the game. They had to love it enough to play it for almost nothing. In the late 1880s, salaries for ballplayers "ranged between $50 and $60 per month, although top pitchers and catchers sometimes earned $75 monthly." In 1900, when the Southern Association was founded, the team rosters were limited to 12 players, and the monthly salary was limited to $1,200--for the whole team. "No star earned as much as $100 per month."


Unlike today's teams, which fly from city to city in first-class comfort aboard jet airplanes, players "back in the day" traveled by rail in day coaches. If the trip involved an overnight ride, they slept two men to a berth. And they stayed in cheap flop houses during any series away from their home fields.


"Shoeless" Joe Jackson
"Shoeless" Joe Jackson

Yes, those players were tough, true athletes who could do it all. And many of those minor league players made it to "the bigs," the major leagues, and did well. For example, Joe Jackson (aka "Shoeless Joe") and Tris Speaker. Unfortunately, Jackson and seven other Chicago White Sox players were later implicated in the infamous "Black Sox Scandal" in 1919. Speaker won batting championships in both the Texas League and the Southern Association in 1907 and 1908,

Tris Speaker, Hall of Famer
Tris Speaker, Hall of Famer

respectively, and "led the league in runs, doubles, and putouts and assists by an outfielder." He ended up playing 20 years in the American League and was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.


You can talk all you want about all the power hitters of today and the strikeout kings. But I still think that given the conditions in which the "old-timers" played, they were far better athletes than those who play today. They played harder, with more enthusiasm and determination, and with fewer amenities and benefits--because they truly loved the game more than money or fame.



You can read more about the minor leagues of old, especially the teams of the South, in The Southern League: Baseball in Dixie by Bill O'Neil (Eakin Press, Austin, Texas, 1994). (All quotations in this post were taken from that source.) You might even agree with my conclusion about the contrast between players of yore and the pampered, overpaid media hounds playing the game today. Or you might not. But either way, we can all enjoy "America's first team sport," the American pastime.

 
 
 

Comments


Follow

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

©2025 by Dennis L. Peterson

bottom of page